If we were to delve seriously into the question, “What is a revolution” or “What defines a revolution”, I think we would get at the heart of the matter – i.e. not just what is wrong with the IMT and all of its failings, but the general problems of Marxism in general.
Since we first declared the Albanian and Indonesian revolutions in the late 1990s I seriously began to question the declaration of a revolution at every turn that the IMT seems to do… Suddenly there were revolutions everywhere – Albania, Indonesia, Ecuador, Argentina, Venezuela, Mexico, Haiti, Kyrgystan, Iran, Thailand etc. have all had revolutions or experienced revolutionary situations apparently within the last 10-15 years. Now, in some cases this may be true, in others I think it is patently not… I first seriously began questioning all this when we declared the Mexican revolution – not because of the Oaxaca commune and the dual power that existed there, but because of the mass protests against the fraud in the election and the events in Mexico city… I think this situation was clarified by the IMT in a much better way subsequently… but still, revolutions have been declared in an entire host of countries, and can we say that there are still revolutions in these countries?
(more…)